What makes a book feel alive? I’ve been circling that question recently, not in a purely theoretical way, but in the way a question circles you when something in your life has sharpened it. This week, my Dad’s first novel, The Pueblo Affair, came out today, a Cold War espionage thriller seeded in his experiences in military intelligence and carried, in one form or another, for nearly six decades. Watching that story move from memory and manuscript into the public world has made me think carefully about what distinguishes a book that merely exists from one that feels inhabited.
There are many competent books. There are books that are structurally sound, stylistically polished, even strategically positioned. Yet some of them remain curiously inert. By contrast, other books — sometimes imperfect, sometimes uneven — seem to generate their own atmosphere. You step into them and feel pressure, motion, and stakes. The difference, I suspect, begins with whether the book is organised around a living question.
In The Art of Fiction, John Gardner writes about the importance of sustaining a “vivid and continuous dream.” That phrase has always stayed with me, but what strikes me more now is that vividness alone is insufficient. A dream can be vivid and still feel unnecessary. The books that endure tend to be structured around questions that have not gone cold for their authors. When Virginia Woolf writes Mrs Dalloway, she is not merely experimenting with stream of consciousness; she is asking what it means to exist in time after rupture, after war, inside a fragile social fabric. When James Baldwinwrites about love and race, the prose carries the voltage of lived moral urgency. Even the pacy espionage worlds of John le Carré are animated by a relentless interrogation of loyalty, betrayal, and institutional compromise.
What I see in my Dad’s novel is precisely that persistence of question. What does it mean to serve something larger than yourself when the structures you serve are morally ambiguous? Aliveness also depends, I think, on moral temperature: there is a felt seriousness about human choice, consequence, and limitation. This is true of literary modernism, which has been central to my own scholarship, but it is equally true of genre fiction when it is done well. An espionage thriller that merely orchestrates plot twists can entertain; one that probes the cost of secrecy and divided loyalty begins to breathe.
Where do we misrecognise ourselves in others? How do our attachment patterns shape narrative form? A living book is anchored in particularity. It smells of specific rooms, contains the weight of actual objects, carries the tonalities of real conversations. In The Pueblo Affair, the atmosphere of late-1960s intelligence culture, the soundtrack of the era, the moral ambiguity of clandestine meetings in Washington bars, all contribute to a sense that the narrative has density. Specificity signals that the writer has metabolised experience rather than merely arranged information.
When writers attempt to anticipate reception, market trends, or institutional approval at the expense of their real preoccupations, the work thins. When they are willing to risk clarity about what matters to them, the prose acquires voltage.
Watching my Dad publish his first novel at this stage of life has so wonderful. As I continue writing, teaching, and working with other creatives, I am increasingly convinced that our task is less to manufacture creativity and more to remove the obstructions to it. When the writer is alive to their own question, their own moral temperature, their own tempo, the book has a chance to live as well.
Upcoming Events
Creative Flow Co-Working Session: Reclaiming Your Time |23 February | 10 AM-12 PM GMT | FREE
Register here: https://www.meetup.com/the-art-of-creative-practice/events/312151263/
Beyond Time Management: A More Natural Way to Organise Creative Work | 24 February | 7.30-9.00 PM GMT | £12
Register here: https://www.meetup.com/the-art-of-creative-practice/events/313062163/
5 Days of Creative Abundance | 9-13 March | 7.30-8.00 PM GMT | £29
Register here: https://www.meetup.com/the-art-of-creative-practice/events/313206797/
The Writer’s Flow Circle: A 12-Week Group Coaching Circle | Beginning Monday 23 March | 7.30-9.00 PM UK time | £180
Register here: https://www.meetup.com/the-art-of-creative-practice/events/313207235/
More to Explore
Discover more from Allan Johnson, PhD
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
